For used car shoppers, reliability is paramount – especially when venturing into hybrid technology. A quarter-century of hybrid development means today’s used market offers proven choices, not just “bargains.” Smart buyers aren’t chasing novelty; they’re prioritizing low operating costs and avoiding expensive repairs. Depreciation unlocks savings, but neglected components only become pricier with time. The best used hybrids have longevity, proven software, and a track record of minimal shop visits.
This list ranks models based on extensive research, from least to most reliable. The data is current as of this publishing date, but used car conditions vary, so due diligence is always advised.
10. 2022 BMW 540i (Reliability Score: 88/100)
The BMW 5 Series remains a benchmark for sports sedans, blending performance with luxury. The 2022 540i, with its mild-hybrid engine, earns solid ratings in owner surveys, particularly for quality and driving experience. However, BMW ownership isn’t cheap.
- Fair Purchase Price: $33,000–$38,000 (KBB)
- Average Yearly Maintenance: $798 (RepairPal)
- 10-Year Maintenance Cost: $14,525 (CarEdge)
- Major Repair Chance (10 years): 41.7%
While refined, the 540i is about 50% more expensive to maintain than the average luxury car.
9. 2009 Toyota Prius (Reliability Score: 89/100)
The 2009 Prius helped mainstream hybrid acceptance. Decades of data show fewer defects than many contemporaries, building confidence among buyers seeking dependability.
- Current Market Value: ~$5,000
- Average Yearly Maintenance: $410 (RepairPal)
- 10-Year Maintenance Cost: $4,360 (CarEdge)
- Major Repair Chance (10 years): 11.4%
The Prius isn’t glamorous, but it delivers on its promise of reliability at an accessible price.
8. 2015 Lexus GS 450h (Reliability Score: 89/100)
The 2015 Lexus GS 450h is an underappreciated gem. It consistently scores high in owner surveys, thanks to Lexus’s reputation for durable powertrains and long-term ownership satisfaction.
- Fair Purchase Price: $23,300 (KBB)
- Average Yearly Maintenance: $678 (RepairPal)
- 10-Year Maintenance Cost: $7,110 (CarEdge)
- Recalls: 0
Lexus’s reliability is well-established, making this a smart long-term buy.
7. 2019 Lincoln MKZ Hybrid (Reliability Score: 89/100)
The 2019 Lincoln MKZ Hybrid combined luxury with fuel efficiency, outperforming some German competitors. Owner surveys show comparatively few defects.
- Fair Purchase Price: $15,500–$17,500 (KBB)
- Average Yearly Maintenance: $831 (RepairPal)
- 10-Year Maintenance Cost: $12,416 (CarEdge)
- Recalls: 0
The MKZ represents a peak in Lincoln engineering before the brand shifted focus.
6. 2019 Hyundai Sonata Hybrid (Reliability Score: 89/100)
The 2019 Hyundai Sonata Hybrid has evolved into a highly reliable option, challenging established Japanese models. Owner surveys reflect comfort, competence, and positive reliability perceptions.
- Fair Purchase Price: $12,000–$15,400 (KBB)
- Average Yearly Maintenance: $458 (RepairPal)
- 10-Year Maintenance Cost: $6,444 (CarEdge)
- Major Repair Chance (10 years): 18.3%
The Sonata’s reliability has improved significantly over the years, making it a compelling choice.
5. 2019 Buick LaCrosse With eAssist (Reliability Score: 90/100)
The 2019 Buick LaCrosse with eAssist is a forgotten hybrid that delivers efficiency and comfort. Owners consistently rate it highly for body integrity and ride quality.
- Market Value: $15,000–$20,000
- Average Yearly Maintenance: $569 (RepairPal)
- 10-Year Maintenance Cost: $8,993 (CarEdge)
- Major Repair Chance (10 years): 26%
The LaCrosse offers above-average reliability at a reasonable price.
4. 2025 Porsche 911 GTS T-Hybrid (Reliability Score: 91/100)
The 2025 Porsche 911 GTS T-Hybrid marks Porsche’s first hybrid take on the rear-engine layout. Power surveys also highlight owners’ satisfaction with the company’s dealer network.
- Market Value: $166,000–$180,000
- Average Yearly Maintenance: $1,072 (RepairPal)
- 10-Year Maintenance Cost: $10,760 (CarEdge)
- Major Repair Chance (10 years): 41.7%
The Porsche 911 is the only sports car on the list that makes sense to buy used.
3. 2021 Toyota Avalon Hybrid (Reliability Score: 92/100)
The 2021 Toyota Avalon Hybrid is a top pick in the used market, thanks to Toyota’s Hybrid Synergy Drive system. It delivers durability, quiet operation, and exceptional fuel efficiency.
- Fair Purchase Price: $24,000–$28,000 (KBB)
- Average Yearly Maintenance: $463 (RepairPal)
- 10-Year Maintenance Cost: $5,470 (CarEdge)
- Recalls: 1
The Avalon is a reliable and comfortable choice for buyers seeking a premium large car.
2. 2014 Toyota Camry Hybrid (Reliability Score: 92/100)
The 2014 Toyota Camry Hybrid sets the standard for hybrid reliability. Its depreciation is slow, but its longevity and low maintenance costs make it a total bargain.
- Current Market Value: ~$11,000
- Average Yearly Maintenance: $387 (RepairPal)
- 10-Year Maintenance Cost: $4,581 (CarEdge)
- Major Repair Chance (10 years): 12%
The Camry Hybrid remains the benchmark for reliability in its class.
1. 2017 Lexus ES 300h (Reliability Score: 96/100)
The 2017 Lexus ES 300h consistently ranks high in owner surveys, with minimal defects and above-average service quality. It delivers exceptional cabin comfort, ride quality, and powertrain refinement.
- Market Value: $18,550
- Average Yearly Maintenance: $430 (RepairPal)
- 10-Year Maintenance Cost: $5,300 (CarEdge)
- Recalls: 0
The ES 300h is the most reliable sedan on the used market, combining luxury with dependability.
Conclusion: The used hybrid market offers excellent value for buyers prioritizing reliability. Toyota and Lexus models consistently lead the way, but even luxury brands like BMW can provide dependable options if maintained properly. By focusing on proven track records and avoiding high-risk years, buyers can secure long-term savings and peace of mind.
